London Banter

London Banter (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/forum.php)
-   London Transport (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/london-transport/)
-   -   HEX Ripoff .... (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/london-transport/14131-hex-ripoff.html)

CJB November 28th 14 11:41 AM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...ht-MALAGA.html


Roland Perry November 28th 14 01:42 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
In message , at
04:41:31 on Fri, 28 Nov 2014, CJB remarked:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...ess-tops-list-
tickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html


I think you'll find a taxi is even more expensive.
--
Roland Perry

eastender[_4_] November 28th 14 05:15 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 2014-11-28 12:41:31 +0000, CJB said:

More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...ht-MALAGA.html


It's not even much faster if you're going to/from say Dalston where I
am - the Piccadilly is only about 15 mins longer and the changes are
easier.

E.


tim..... November 28th 14 06:13 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 

"Roland Perry" wrote in message
...
In message , at
04:41:31 on Fri, 28 Nov 2014, CJB remarked:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...ess-tops-list-
tickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html


I think you'll find a taxi is even more expensive.


and I think they meant the "EU" as Oslo is even more expensive

tim







eastender[_4_] November 28th 14 06:32 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 2014-11-28 19:13:55 +0000, tim..... said:

"Roland Perry" wrote in message
...
In message , at
04:41:31 on Fri, 28 Nov 2014, CJB remarked:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...ess-tops-list-

tickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html


I think you'll find a taxi is even more expensive.


and I think they meant the "EU" as Oslo is even more expensive


Arlanda (Stockholm) is about £22 one way, a pound more than HEX. I've
forked out for this a few times.

E.


Robin9 November 29th 14 07:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roland Perry (Post 145904)
In message , at
04:41:31 on Fri, 28 Nov 2014, CJB
remarked:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...ess-tops-list-
tickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html


I think you'll find a taxi is even more expensive.
--
Roland Perry

If you're travelling alone. If you share the taxi - and the cost- with other
people, the cost per person is quite reasonable for the door-to-door
convenience.

I'm always surprised when I see entire families travelling to and from airports
by public transport.

Roland Perry November 29th 14 08:34 AM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
In message , at 18:15:22 on Fri,
28 Nov 2014, eastender remarked:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...1805/London-fo
ur-five-expensive-airport-transfers-Europe-Heathrow-Express-tops-list-t
ickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html


It's not even much faster if you're going to/from say Dalston where I
am - the Piccadilly is only about 15 mins longer and the changes are
easier.


Such a shame, then, that everyone is forced to use HEx, and no
passengers are allowed to use other ways of getting to the airport.
--
Roland Perry

Recliner[_3_] November 29th 14 08:49 AM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
Roland Perry wrote:
In message , at 18:15:22 on Fri,
28 Nov 2014, eastender remarked:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...1805/London-fo
ur-five-expensive-airport-transfers-Europe-Heathrow-Express-tops-list-t
ickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html


It's not even much faster if you're going to/from say Dalston where I
am - the Piccadilly is only about 15 mins longer and the changes are easier.


Such a shame, then, that everyone is forced to use HEx, and no passengers
are allowed to use other ways of getting to the airport.


I wonder if someone has figures for HEx, HC and Picc loading from Heathrow.
HEx has 4tph, HC has 2tph and the PIcc has at least 12tph in the peaks.

Roland Perry November 29th 14 09:32 AM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
In message , at 09:46:45 on Sat, 29
Nov 2014, Robin9 remarked:

Roland Perry;145904 Wrote:
In message , at
04:41:31 on Fri, 28 Nov 2014, CJB
remarked:-
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...

http://tinyurl.com/kt2kplh
tickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html-

I think you'll find a taxi is even more expensive.


If you're travelling alone. If you share the taxi - and the cost- with
other people, the cost per person is quite reasonable for the
door-to-door convenience.


A taxi can also be cheaper than a week's parking at many airports.

I'm always surprised when I see entire families travelling to and from
airports by public transport.


Force of habit, perhaps.


--
Roland Perry

Neil Williams November 29th 14 10:09 AM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 2014-11-29 08:46:45 +0000, Robin9 said:

I'm always surprised when I see entire families travelling to and from
airports
by public transport.


There are other reasons - for instance, in some areas taxi drivers are
very unreliable, drive dangerously or both. If you make the comparison
with a premium airport car service instead, sometimes the balance may
well tip in favour of public transport, particularly coach or if Family
Railcards are applicable.

Neil
--
Neil Williams
Put my first name before the @ to reply.


Roland Perry November 29th 14 10:59 AM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
In message
-septemb
er.org, at 09:49:05 on Sat, 29 Nov 2014, Recliner
remarked:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...1805/London-fo
ur-five-expensive-airport-transfers-Europe-Heathrow-Express-tops-list-t
ickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html

It's not even much faster if you're going to/from say Dalston where I
am - the Piccadilly is only about 15 mins longer and the changes are easier.


Such a shame, then, that everyone is forced to use HEx, and no passengers
are allowed to use other ways of getting to the airport.


I wonder if someone has figures for HEx, HC and Picc loading from Heathrow.
HEx has 4tph, HC has 2tph and the PIcc has at least 12tph in the peaks.


I posted all the numbers about six months ago in a previous thread.
--
Roland Perry

Recliner[_3_] November 29th 14 11:29 AM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On Sat, 29 Nov 2014 11:59:12 +0000, Roland Perry
wrote:

In message
-septemb
er.org, at 09:49:05 on Sat, 29 Nov 2014, Recliner
remarked:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...1805/London-fo
ur-five-expensive-airport-transfers-Europe-Heathrow-Express-tops-list-t
ickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html

It's not even much faster if you're going to/from say Dalston where I
am - the Piccadilly is only about 15 mins longer and the changes are easier.

Such a shame, then, that everyone is forced to use HEx, and no passengers
are allowed to use other ways of getting to the airport.


I wonder if someone has figures for HEx, HC and Picc loading from Heathrow.
HEx has 4tph, HC has 2tph and the PIcc has at least 12tph in the peaks.


I posted all the numbers about six months ago in a previous thread.


Yes, I thought you had posted them a while ago, but couldn't remember
when.

eastender[_4_] November 29th 14 01:15 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 2014-11-29 09:49:05 +0000, Recliner said:

Roland Perry wrote:
In message , at 18:15:22 on Fri,
28 Nov 2014, eastender remarked:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...1805/London-fo
ur-five-expensive-airport-transfers-Europe-Heathrow-Express-tops-list-t
ickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html

It's not even much faster if you're going to/from say Dalston where I
am - the Piccadilly is only about 15 mins longer and the changes are easier.


Such a shame, then, that everyone is forced to use HEx, and no passengers
are allowed to use other ways of getting to the airport.


I wonder if someone has figures for HEx, HC and Picc loading from Heathrow.
HEx has 4tph, HC has 2tph and the PIcc has at least 12tph in the peaks.


Good point - if you just miss a HEx the time advanatge almost disappears.

E.



Recliner[_3_] November 29th 14 01:24 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
eastender wrote:
On 2014-11-29 09:49:05 +0000, Recliner said:

Roland Perry wrote:
In message , at 18:15:22 on Fri,
28 Nov 2014, eastender remarked:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...1805/London-fo
ur-five-expensive-airport-transfers-Europe-Heathrow-Express-tops-list-t
ickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html
It's not even much faster if you're going to/from say Dalston where I
am - the Piccadilly is only about 15 mins longer and the changes are easier.
Such a shame, then, that everyone is forced to use HEx, and no passengers
are allowed to use other ways of getting to the airport.
I wonder if someone has figures for HEx, HC and Picc loading from Heathrow.

HEx has 4tph, HC has 2tph and the PIcc has at least 12tph in the peaks.


Good point - if you just miss a HEx the time advanatge almost disappears.

Though, to be fair, the full Picc service is only available from T123; it's
only half the frequency from T4 and T5. But then, T4 doesn't have a direct
HEx service either, and T5 doesn't get HC. Crossrail will help, but in
time, the Picc will also have a more frequent service.

hounslow3@yahoo.co.uk November 29th 14 04:10 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 28.11.14 12:41, CJB wrote:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...ht-MALAGA.html

Southampton to Alderney is probably one of the most expensive flights
per mile at about £250 return.

Robin9 November 29th 14 09:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil Williams (Post 145912)
On 2014-11-29 08:46:45 +0000, Robin9 said:

I'm always surprised when I see entire families travelling to and from
airports
by public transport.


There are other reasons - for instance, in some areas taxi drivers are
very unreliable, drive dangerously or both. If you make the comparison
with a premium airport car service instead, sometimes the balance may
well tip in favour of public transport, particularly coach or if Family
Railcards are applicable.

Neil
--
Neil Williams
Put my first name before the @ to reply.

I assume - please correct me if I'm wrong - that you're referring to some
minicab drivers. Certainly it is the case that there are some really awful
minicab drivers in London who drive dangerously, are rude and/or unhelpful,
overcharge and keep neither their cars not themselves clean.

Almost every minicab firm in the London area has at least some drivers who do
not fit the above description. The prudent customer, when booking the cab,
asks that "a nice driver" is allocated to them. If the cab firm is any good, the
controller will understand what the customer is worrying about and will provide
a decent driver.

Neil Williams November 30th 14 05:36 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 2014-11-29 22:19:01 +0000, Robin9 said:

I assume - please correct me if I'm wrong - that you're referring to
some
minicab drivers.


In London probably yes, and as this is uk.transport.london I should
perhaps have been clearer.

Outside London it is my experience that it is the black cabs that are
generally less reputable. Certainly if anyone is going to try to avoid
charging the correct rate in Milton Keynes late at night it's the black
cabs. The three main minicab operators (the term "minicab" is a London
thing, elsewhere they are referred to as taxis, even if that is
technically incorrect) are generally reputable and well-behaved, though
you do occasionally encounter the odd exception.

Certainly it is the case that there are some really
awful
minicab drivers in London who drive dangerously, are rude and/or
unhelpful,
overcharge and keep neither their cars not themselves clean.

Almost every minicab firm in the London area has at least some drivers
who do
not fit the above description. The prudent customer, when booking the
cab,
asks that "a nice driver" is allocated to them. If the cab firm is any
good, the
controller will understand what the customer is worrying about and will
provide
a decent driver.


That is laughably ridiculous even if it might work. I shouldn't have
to request a driver who complies fully with the law and their contract
with their company regarding fares, nor a clean car in a good state of
repair. Every driver should do that without being asked. If they
don't, they deserve the sack or to be prosecuted, depending on whether
they have breached the law or merely their contract.

Neil
--
Neil Williams
Put my first name before the @ to reply.


Robin9 December 1st 14 09:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil Williams (Post 145926)
On 2014-11-29 22:19:01 +0000, Robin9 said:

I assume - please correct me if I'm wrong - that you're referring to
some
minicab drivers.


In London probably yes, and as this is uk.transport.london I should
perhaps have been clearer.

Outside London it is my experience that it is the black cabs that are
generally less reputable. Certainly if anyone is going to try to avoid
charging the correct rate in Milton Keynes late at night it's the black
cabs. The three main minicab operators (the term "minicab" is a London
thing, elsewhere they are referred to as taxis, even if that is
technically incorrect) are generally reputable and well-behaved, though
you do occasionally encounter the odd exception.

Certainly it is the case that there are some really awful minicab drivers in
London who drive dangerously, are rude and/or unhelpful, overcharge and
keep neither their cars not themselves clean.

Almost every minicab firm in the London area has at least some drivers
who do not fit the above description. The prudent customer, when booking
the cab, asks that "a nice driver" is allocated to them. If the cab firm is any
good, the controller will understand what the customer is worrying about and
will provide a decent driver.


That is laughably ridiculous even if it might work. I shouldn't have
to request a driver who complies fully with the law and their contract
with their company regarding fares, nor a clean car in a good state of
repair. Every driver should do that without being asked. If they
don't, they deserve the sack or to be prosecuted, depending on whether
they have breached the law or merely their contract.

Neil
--
Neil Williams
Put my first name before the @ to reply.

We're not discussing what should be the case. We're discussing what is the
case; and it is definitely the case that most minicab firms in London are so
concerned to have as many drivers as possible that they ignore other
considerations.

In London it is quite common for customers to request a civilized driver when
booking a car for a non-local journey.

Mizter T December 1st 14 02:44 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 

On 01/12/2014 10:33, Robin9 wrote:
[...]
Certainly it is the case that there are some really awful minicab
drivers in London who drive dangerously, are rude and/or unhelpful,
overcharge and keep neither their cars not themselves clean.

Almost every minicab firm in the London area has at least some drivers
who do not fit the above description. The prudent customer, when booking

the cab, asks that "a nice driver" is allocated to them. If the cab firm
is any
good, the controller will understand what the customer is worrying about
and
will provide a decent driver.-

That is laughably ridiculous even if it might work. I shouldn't have
to request a driver who complies fully with the law and their contract
with their company regarding fares, nor a clean car in a good state of
repair. Every driver should do that without being asked. If they
don't, they deserve the sack or to be prosecuted, depending on whether
they have breached the law or merely their contract.


We're not discussing what should be the case. We're discussing what is
the case; and it is definitely the case that most minicab firms in London
London are so concerned to have as many drivers as possible that they
ignore other considerations.

In London it is quite common for customers to request a civilized driver
when booking a car for a non-local journey.


Is it? This is a bit of a new concept to me - "don't send me the psycho
please"!

Neil Williams December 1st 14 03:38 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 2014-12-01 10:33:17 +0000, Robin9 said:

In London it is quite common for customers to request a civilized driver
when
booking a car for a non-local journey.


I don't disbelieve you, I just think it's a joke that it is legal and
accepted for this to be the case.

Neil
--
Neil Williams
Put my first name before the @ to reply.


JNugent[_5_] December 1st 14 06:25 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 29/11/2014 10:32, Roland Perry wrote:

Robin9 remarked:
Roland Perry;145904 Wrote:
CJB remarked:-


More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...


http://tinyurl.com/kt2kplh
tickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html-


I think you'll find a taxi is even more expensive.


If you're travelling alone. If you share the taxi - and the cost- with
other people, the cost per person is quite reasonable for the
door-to-door convenience.


A taxi can also be cheaper than a week's parking at many airports.


You usually have to be living fairly close to the airport (and certainly
around its nominal names town or city) for that to be the case. I live
over 70m from Heathrow. There is no way that a taxi (both ways) can
compete with parking at the airport. At least, not just in cost.

Michael R N Dolbear December 1st 14 07:26 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
"JNugent" wrote

I think you'll find a taxi is even more expensive.


If you're travelling alone. If you share the taxi - and the cost- with
other people, the cost per person is quite reasonable for the
door-to-door convenience.


A taxi can also be cheaper than a week's parking at many airports.


You usually have to be living fairly close to the airport (and certainly

around its nominal names town or city) for that to be the case. I live
over 70m from Heathrow. There is no way that a taxi (both ways) can
compete with parking at the airport. At least, not just in cost.


Perhaps we need a optimiser ?

Cheap parking at the airport often needs an extra car to shuttle bus
interchange.

So near-to-airport parking plus taxi is worth pricing as is long-term hotel
parking included in the overnight rate.

And does anyone offer a valet to drive your car from hotel to airport when
you leave and park it afterwards ?


-- --
Mike D


Clive D. W. Feather[_2_] December 2nd 14 06:02 AM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
In message , "
wrote:
On 28.11.14 12:41, CJB wrote:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...1805/London-fo
ur-five-expensive-airport-transfers-Europe-Heathrow-Express-tops-list-t
ickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html

Southampton to Alderney is probably one of the most expensive flights
per mile at about £250 return.


Does WRY to PPW still operate? That might well be the record price.

--
Clive D.W. Feather | Home:
Mobile: +44 7973 377646 | Web: http://www.davros.org
Please reply to the Reply-To address, which is:

Roland Perry December 2nd 14 10:35 AM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
In message , at 20:26:33 on Mon, 1 Dec
2014, Michael R N Dolbear remarked:
A taxi can also be cheaper than a week's parking at many airports.


You usually have to be living fairly close to the airport (and
certainly around its nominal names town or city) for that to be the
case. I live over 70m from Heathrow. There is no way that a taxi (both
ways) can compete with parking at the airport. At least, not just in cost.


There's obviously going to be a break-even point, although 140m in a car
is going to cost £30 on top of the parking, just counting marginal
costs.

I looked up long stay parking at Heathrow just now, and it's £145 a
week, with an "offer" of £77 at the moment.

When I used to fly from Birmingham it was 50m each way and a taxi was
cheaper than a week in their mid-stay car park. And of course the car
was available for other people to use at home, while I was away. The
other solution is for them to give you a lift to the airport, if they
have the odd three hours to spare, twice.

--
Roland Perry

hounslow3@yahoo.co.uk December 2nd 14 10:54 AM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 02.12.14 7:02, Clive D. W. Feather wrote:
In message , "
wrote:
On 28.11.14 12:41, CJB wrote:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...1805/London-fo
ur-five-expensive-airport-transfers-Europe-Heathrow-Express-tops-list-t
ickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html

Southampton to Alderney is probably one of the most expensive flights
per mile at about £250 return.


Does WRY to PPW still operate? That might well be the record price.

Yes, it does, though I don't know the price.

David Cantrell December 2nd 14 12:41 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On Mon, Dec 01, 2014 at 11:33:17AM +0100, Robin9 wrote:

In London it is quite common for customers to request a civilized driver
when booking a car for a non-local journey.


If it were common I think I would have heard of it at least once in the
last nearly twenty years.

I haven't.

I've heard of cab firms getting requests for drivers of particular
races, but that is of course not the same as requesting a driver who
knows how to drive and keeps his car clean.

--
David Cantrell | Cake Smuggler Extraordinaire

Human Rights left unattended may be removed,
destroyed, or damaged by the security services.

hounslow3@yahoo.co.uk December 2nd 14 02:12 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 02.12.14 7:02, Clive D. W. Feather wrote:
In message , "
wrote:
On 28.11.14 12:41, CJB wrote:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...1805/London-fo
ur-five-expensive-airport-transfers-Europe-Heathrow-Express-tops-list-t
ickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html

Southampton to Alderney is probably one of the most expensive flights
per mile at about £250 return.


Does WRY to PPW still operate? That might well be the record price.


It wouldn't surprise me if the ticket price from WRY to PPW is much
different for locals than for outsiders -- mostly people looking to say
that they did the world's shortest flight.

I know that residents of Alderney pay a much lower fare to travel by air
to Guernsey than non-residents do. The same also applies for flights
between St. Pierre and Miquelon.

IIRC, the ferry from St. Peter Port to Sark also had a double fare
structure.



Theo Markettos December 2nd 14 06:16 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
wrote:
On 02.12.14 7:02, Clive D. W. Feather wrote:
In message , "
wrote:
On 28.11.14 12:41, CJB wrote:
More expensive per mile than Concorde was ...


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/tr...1805/London-fo
ur-five-expensive-airport-transfers-Europe-Heathrow-Express-tops-list-t
ickets-cost-return-flight-MALAGA.html

Southampton to Alderney is probably one of the most expensive flights
per mile at about £250 return.


Does WRY to PPW still operate? That might well be the record price.


Yes, GBP17 one way:
http://www.loganair.co.uk/xtra_files/OrkneyFares.pdf

It wouldn't surprise me if the ticket price from WRY to PPW is much
different for locals than for outsiders -- mostly people looking to say
that they did the world's shortest flight.


There's an Island Saver discounted return fare to Kirkwall originating in the North
Isles, which you don't get if you do it the other way return. Though the
Excursion fare (stay at least one night) is decent value for originating
there.

Theo

JNugent[_5_] December 2nd 14 11:38 PM

HEX Ripoff ....
 
On 01/12/2014 20:26, Michael R N Dolbear wrote:
"JNugent" wrote

I think you'll find a taxi is even more expensive.


If you're travelling alone. If you share the taxi - and the cost-
with other people, the cost per person is quite reasonable for the
door-to-door convenience.


A taxi can also be cheaper than a week's parking at many airports.


You usually have to be living fairly close to the airport (and certainly

around its nominal names town or city) for that to be the case. I live
over 70m from Heathrow. There is no way that a taxi (both ways) can
compete with parking at the airport. At least, not just in cost.


Perhaps we need a optimiser ?

Cheap parking at the airport often needs an extra car to shuttle bus
interchange.


That (the bus) is always provided at major airport car-parks.

So near-to-airport parking plus taxi is worth pricing as is long-term
hotel parking included in the overnight rate.


Not necessary.

And does anyone offer a valet to drive your car from hotel to airport
when you leave and park it afterwards ?


The place I use offers that as an extra service, at an extra charge.


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:18 PM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2006 LondonBanter.co.uk