London Banter

London Banter (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/forum.php)
-   London Transport (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/london-transport/)
-   -   Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/london-transport/7322-fares-shepherds-bush-overground.html)

[email protected] December 4th 08 01:22 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
I'm going to a comedy recording at Wood Lane on Friday so I thought I
would change at Clapham Junction for the new Shepherds Bush overground
station.

When I looked it up on the National rail Enquiries website I was
surprised to find that the cheapest off peak return is £16.00. I can
get a return to London with travelcard for £16.80! A return to
Clapham Junction is £11.50 and from C Jn to Shep Bush is £3.00 so I am
surprised that a through ticket is more expensive.

The SWT ticket machines don't seem to list Shepherds Bush so I was
unable to check on that.

So what is the cheapest fare? Or can I rely on a Fleet to London
Stations ticket?

Thx, Phil

[email protected] December 4th 08 01:27 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
..

So what is the cheapest fare? *Or can I rely on a Fleet to London
Stations ticket?

Thx, *Phil


If you have a Fleet to London Terminals season ticket this will cover
you to Clapham Junction. Not sure about the last bit, would probably
say yes but I am sure one of our routing guide experts will be along
to comment shortly!


Mr Thant December 4th 08 01:36 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On 4 Dec, 14:22, wrote:
I'm going to a comedy recording at Wood Lane on Friday so I thought I
would change at Clapham Junction for the new Shepherds Bush overground
station.


It's a fair old walk, although I guess you could go through Westfield
on the way (or you can walk along the south side of it without
venturing in). But I'd get the tube from SB to WC.

When I looked it up on the National rail Enquiries website I was
surprised to find that the cheapest off peak return is £16.00. *I can
get a return to London with travelcard for £16.80! *


That's super-off peak, which means it's valid on fewer trains to
London than the £16 off-peak ticket, although this may not affect you.

A return to
Clapham Junction is £11.50 and from C Jn to Shep Bush is £3.00 so I am
surprised that a through ticket is more expensive.


But the £11.50 is super-off peak. The off-peak fare to CJ is £14.10,
which fits with the £16 off-peak to SB. There doesn't seem to be a
super off-peak fare to Shepherd's Bush, hence the anomaly.

U

[email protected] December 4th 08 01:41 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On 4 Dec, 14:27, wrote:
.



So what is the cheapest fare? *Or can I rely on a Fleet to London
Stations ticket?


Thx, *Phil


If you have a Fleet to London Terminals season ticket this will cover
you to Clapham Junction. *Not sure about the last bit, would probably
say yes but I am sure one of our routing guide experts will be along
to comment shortly!


No, I'll be buying a ticket on the day. I have a Network Card so it
doesn't make much difference what I get (the min fare is £10, a
discounted £16.00 fare will cost me about £10.70, and a discounted
Travelcard is £11.30 IIRC) but I was interested in why a return to
Shep Bush via CJn was so expensive compared with a return to Waterloo
plus travelcard, or indeed a return to CJn plus CJn/SB return (or even
Oyster). It's doubly annoying if it isn't on the SWT ticket machine
as I'll have to go to the station when it's actually open, which is
getting rarer.

John B December 4th 08 01:51 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On Dec 4, 2:27*pm, wrote:
So what is the cheapest fare? *Or can I rely on a Fleet to London
Stations ticket?


If you have a Fleet to London Terminals season ticket this will cover
you to Clapham Junction. *Not sure about the last bit, would probably
say yes but I am sure one of our routing guide experts will be along
to comment shortly!


*waves*.

Fleet to London Terminals tickets are routed by maps CS and WR, or by
map WX. Map WX covers Fleet to Clapham Junction (it's basically the
SWT map), but not beyond - it only gets you into Waterloo or Victoria.

Maps CS and WR cover the GWML route into London via Reading and
Slough. They also allow you to travel via Hayes, Kensington Olympia
and Clapham into Waterloo. If you were to go this way, and catch one
of the occasional XC services that takes the route, then this'd get
you as far as Olympia... however, you'd still have to pay gbp3 for the
return Olympia-Shepherds Bush fare, as well as taking a ridiculous
route.

So it sounds like a Fleet to Clapham off-peak return at gbp11.20 and a
Clapham to Shepherds Bush off-peak return at gbp3 are the way forward.
No idea why the through fare is so expensive tho'.

--
John Band
john at johnband dot org
www.johnband.org

[email protected] December 4th 08 01:57 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On 4 Dec, 14:36, Mr Thant
wrote:

But the £11.50 is super-off peak. The off-peak fare to CJ is £14.10,
which fits with the £16 off-peak to SB. There doesn't seem to be a
super off-peak fare to Shepherd's Bush, hence the anomaly.

U


I've checked. NRE is giving me no off peak or super off peak returns
between Shepherds Bush and CJn, the £3 return is "anytime". For some
reason it will give me an off peak to CJn + return to SB, but not a
super off peak. Not sure why it should do one or not the other? I
thought super off peak was the old cheap day return and the off peak
was a new fare designed to make people pay more if they travel just
after the morning peak - so I would have thought that Super Off Peaks
would always be available. But obviously not.

Thank you for the tip off on distances, it didn't look too bad on
Google Maps. It might be better to get a travelcard anyway.

[email protected] December 4th 08 02:07 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On 4 Dec, 14:51, John B wrote:
On Dec 4, 2:27*pm, wrote:

Maps CS and WR cover the GWML route into London via Reading and
Slough. They also allow you to travel via Hayes, Kensington Olympia
and Clapham into Waterloo.


Thx. I thought it might be valid on the WLL, I think I might have
used my old season ticket to Olympia before, hadn't really realised
that was where the validity ended.

So it sounds like a Fleet to Clapham off-peak return at gbp11.20 and a
Clapham to Shepherds Bush off-peak return at gbp3 are the way forward.


I'm on a Network card so it will be a £16 return or a travelcard.

No idea why the through fare is so expensive tho'.


It looks like there are now only TfL fares on that route, not NR ones,
and you can't combine them with a super off peak.

So for some reason it seems you can book "anytime return to CJ +
anytime return from CJ to SB" or "off peak return to CJ + anytime
return from CJ to SB" but not "super off peak return to CJ + anytime
return from CJ to SB".

The NRE website doesn't give the London Stations fare for Olympia
either.

Oh how I miss my season ticket, it was all much easier then!
(Especially now you can use Oyster on the WLL)

Neil Williams December 4th 08 03:05 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On 4 Dec, 14:36, Mr Thant
wrote:

But the £11.50 is super-off peak. The off-peak fare to CJ is £14.10,
which fits with the £16 off-peak to SB. There doesn't seem to be a
super off-peak fare to Shepherd's Bush, hence the anomaly.


A similar one exists for MKC-BHM, which I'm led to believe will be
corrected in January. In the meantime, if you want a weekend day
return for that route, a Super Off-Peak Return from MKC to Stafford is
what you want, as it's 4 quid cheaper than the CDR to Brum.

Neil

Graeme Wall December 4th 08 03:33 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
In message
John B wrote:

On Dec 4, 2:27*pm, wrote:
So what is the cheapest fare? *Or can I rely on a Fleet to London
Stations ticket?


If you have a Fleet to London Terminals season ticket this will cover
you to Clapham Junction. *Not sure about the last bit, would probably
say yes but I am sure one of our routing guide experts will be along
to comment shortly!


*waves*.

Fleet to London Terminals tickets are routed by maps CS and WR, or by
map WX. Map WX covers Fleet to Clapham Junction (it's basically the
SWT map), but not beyond - it only gets you into Waterloo or Victoria.

Maps CS and WR cover the GWML route into London via Reading and
Slough. They also allow you to travel via Hayes, Kensington Olympia
and Clapham into Waterloo. If you were to go this way, and catch one
of the occasional XC services that takes the route, then this'd get
you as far as Olympia... however, you'd still have to pay gbp3 for the
return Olympia-Shepherds Bush fare, as well as taking a ridiculous
route.

So it sounds like a Fleet to Clapham off-peak return at gbp11.20 and a
Clapham to Shepherds Bush off-peak return at gbp3 are the way forward.
No idea why the through fare is so expensive tho'.


Why bother, go to Waterloo then Bakerloo/Northern line (to taste) and then
Central Line to White City which is right opposite TV Centre. Shepherds Bush
is right the other end of Shepherds Bush Green and, frankly, I wouldn't fancy
walking back there from TVC after dark.

--
Graeme Wall
This address is not read, substitute trains for rail.
Transport Miscellany at http://www.greywall.demon.co.uk/rail/index.html

Graham Harrison[_2_] December 4th 08 03:52 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 

"Graeme Wall" wrote in message
...
In message

John B wrote:

On Dec 4, 2:27 pm, wrote:
So what is the cheapest fare? Or can I rely on a Fleet to London
Stations ticket?

If you have a Fleet to London Terminals season ticket this will cover
you to Clapham Junction. Not sure about the last bit, would probably
say yes but I am sure one of our routing guide experts will be along
to comment shortly!


*waves*.

Fleet to London Terminals tickets are routed by maps CS and WR, or by
map WX. Map WX covers Fleet to Clapham Junction (it's basically the
SWT map), but not beyond - it only gets you into Waterloo or Victoria.

Maps CS and WR cover the GWML route into London via Reading and
Slough. They also allow you to travel via Hayes, Kensington Olympia
and Clapham into Waterloo. If you were to go this way, and catch one
of the occasional XC services that takes the route, then this'd get
you as far as Olympia... however, you'd still have to pay gbp3 for the
return Olympia-Shepherds Bush fare, as well as taking a ridiculous
route.

So it sounds like a Fleet to Clapham off-peak return at gbp11.20 and a
Clapham to Shepherds Bush off-peak return at gbp3 are the way forward.
No idea why the through fare is so expensive tho'.


Why bother, go to Waterloo then Bakerloo/Northern line (to taste) and then
Central Line to White City which is right opposite TV Centre. Shepherds
Bush
is right the other end of Shepherds Bush Green and, frankly, I wouldn't
fancy
walking back there from TVC after dark.

--
Graeme Wall
This address is not read, substitute trains for rail.
Transport Miscellany at http://www.greywall.demon.co.uk/rail/index.html


It's counter intuitive but how about Waterloo, Bakerloo or Jubilee to Baker
St then Hammersmith and City to the new station that I can't remember the
name of?

Google

Wood Lane, that's the one.

Or...

Vauxhall, Victoria Line to Victoria, District to Hammersmith H and C to Wood
Lane?


Graeme Wall December 4th 08 04:23 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
In message
"Graham Harrison" wrote:


"Graeme Wall" wrote in message
...

[snip]

Why bother, go to Waterloo then Bakerloo/Northern line (to taste) and
then Central Line to White City which is right opposite TV Centre.
Shepherds Bush is right the other end of Shepherds Bush Green and,
frankly, I wouldn't fancy walking back there from TVC after dark.

-- Graeme Wall This address is not read, substitute trains for rail.
Transport Miscellany at http://www.greywall.demon.co.uk/rail/index.html


It's counter intuitive but how about Waterloo, Bakerloo or Jubilee to Baker
St then Hammersmith and City to the new station that I can't remember the
name of?

Google

Wood Lane, that's the one.

Or...

Vauxhall, Victoria Line to Victoria, District to Hammersmith H and C to
Wood Lane?


That has you trying to cross Hammersmith Broadway which can be interesting,
in the Chinese sense. Still the most logical place is White City especially
if the weather is bad.

--
Graeme Wall
This address is not read, substitute trains for rail.
Transport Miscellany at http://www.greywall.demon.co.uk/rail/index.html

dB December 4th 08 05:45 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
It's a fair old walk, although I guess you could go through Westfield
on the way (or you can walk along the south side of it without
venturing in). But I'd get the tube from SB to WC.

Fair old walk from Shephard's Bush to White City? You can walk it faster
than getting the Central line to go one stop.



Mizter T December 4th 08 10:47 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 

On 4 Dec, 18:45, "dB" wrote:
It's a fair old walk, although I guess you could go through
Westfield on the way (or you can walk along the south side of it
without venturing in). But I'd get the tube from SB to WC.


Fair old walk from Shephard's Bush to White City? You can walk it faster
than getting the Central line to go one stop.


My thoughts exactly.

Mizter T December 4th 08 10:50 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 

On 4 Dec, 14:51, John B wrote:

(snip)

So it sounds like a Fleet to Clapham off-peak return at gbp11.20 and a
Clapham to Shepherds Bush off-peak return at gbp3 are the way forward.
No idea why the through fare is so expensive tho'.


Oyster PAYG is valid on the WLL, so should the OP have an Oyster card
they could use that at a cost of £1 each way so £2 overall.

Mizter T December 4th 08 10:57 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 

On 4 Dec, 16:33, Graeme Wall wrote:

(snip)

Why bother, go to Waterloo then Bakerloo/Northern line (to taste) and then
Central Line to White City which is right opposite TV Centre. *Shepherds Bush
is right the other end of Shepherds Bush Green and, frankly, I wouldn't fancy
walking back there from TVC after dark.


And frankly I wouldn't worry about that.

Anyway, apart from anything else, Westfield is now open until 10pm
weekdays so there's lots of people around, and as Mr Thant says you
can actually walk through the shopping centre if you want.

[email protected] December 4th 08 11:39 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On 4 Dec, 16:52, "Graham Harrison"
wrote:
"Graeme Wall" wrote in message



Why bother, go to Waterloo then Bakerloo/Northern line (to taste) and then
Central Line to White City which is right opposite TV Centre. *Shepherds
Bush
is right the other end of Shepherds Bush Green and, frankly, I wouldn't
fancy
walking back there from TVC after dark.


--
Graeme Wall
This address is not read, substitute trains for rail.
Transport Miscellany at http://www.greywall.demon.co.uk/rail/index.html


It's counter intuitive but how about Waterloo, Bakerloo or Jubilee to Baker
St then Hammersmith and City to the new station that I can't remember the
name of?

Google

Wood Lane, that's the one.


I didn't know they had built a new station... six months not working
in London and it seems I'm out of touch already.

Thanks for all the more or less convoluted ways of getting there by
tube, but Fleet-CJn-Shepherds Bush has the benefit of being only one
change and fairly direct. And as I am meeting friends at 5.45 the WLL
from CJn should have the benefit of being relatively quiet. The walk
should be no more than a mile, via major roads I don't see why that
should be a problem.

Besides I don't think I've ever been north of Olympia on the WLL.

I was trying to save the cost of a travelcard - but without the Super
Off Peak option it isn't worth it. But often, if I'm only likely to
be catching one tube, or using the bus, I go for London Stations
ticket + use of Oyster.


Mizter T December 5th 08 07:57 AM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 

On 5 Dec, 00:39, wrote:

On 4 Dec, 16:52, "Graham Harrison"
wrote:

"Graeme Wall" wrote in message


Why bother, go to Waterloo then Bakerloo/Northern line (to taste)
and then Central Line to White City which is right opposite TV Centre..
Shepherds Bush is right the other end of Shepherds Bush Green and,
frankly, I wouldn't fancy walking back there from TVC after dark.


It's counter intuitive but how about Waterloo, Bakerloo or Jubilee to Baker
St then Hammersmith and City to the new station that I can't remember the
name of?


Google


Wood Lane, that's the one.


I didn't know they had built a new station... six months not working
in London and it seems I'm out of touch already.


Both the new stations at Wood Lane on the H&C and Shepherd's Bush on
the WLL have been built in connection with, and at least partially
financed by, Westfield - i.e. the bods who built, own and run the
mamoth new shopping centre there.


Thanks for all the more or less convoluted ways of getting there by
tube, but Fleet-CJn-Shepherds Bush has the benefit of being only one
change and fairly direct. And as I am meeting friends at 5.45 the WLL
from CJn should have the benefit of being relatively quiet. * The walk
should be no more than a mile, via major roads I don't see why that
should be a problem.


The WLL is pretty busy these days, though more so in the southbound
direction - travelling at 5.45 in the opposite direction definitely
couldn't be described as being relatively quiet!


Besides I don't think I've ever been north of Olympia on the WLL.

I was trying to save the cost of a travelcard - but without the Super
Off Peak option it isn't worth it. *But often, if I'm only likely to
be catching one tube, or using the bus, I go for London Stations
ticket + use of Oyster.


As I state elsewhere on this thread, Oyster PAYG is valid for use on
the WLL these dfays - and that includes from Clapham Junction.

Here's a map of the National Rail routes on which PAYG is currently
valid (PDF):
http://www.tfl.gov.uk/assets/downloa...onal-rail..pdf

[email protected] December 5th 08 08:27 AM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 

As I state elsewhere on this thread, Oyster PAYG is valid for use on
the WLL these dfays - and that includes from Clapham Junction.


Yes I know, but on this occasion it will be better value to get a
through ticket or a travelcard. At the weekend, when the Network Card
cap doesn't apply, it may very well be best to buy a return to CJn and
then use Oyster.

Although one problem with Oyster is that it doesn't allow for change
of mode on one fare. So a journey involving two buses, or a bus and
tube, or maybe here - if it's raining I might want to get the Tube to
Shepherds Bush and then WLL - you get charged twice, more than if you
took a journey of equivalent length on the Tube, even changing lines.

Many European transport systems allow you to change mode on a single
ticket, within a certain amount of time - and I think Oyster should be
programmed to do this.

Mr Thant December 5th 08 12:35 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On 5 Dec, 09:27, wrote:
if it's raining I might want to get the Tube to
Shepherds Bush and then WLL - you get charged twice, more than if you
took a journey of equivalent length on the Tube, even changing lines.


No you don't. Oyster PAYG fares are based on the start and end points
of your journey. If you change trains at a recognised interchange,
even if you have to go through barriers or out onto the street, it
counts as a continuation of the same journey. In other words, in your
scenario, the second leg is free.

U

[email protected] December 5th 08 12:52 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On 5 Dec, 13:35, Mr Thant
wrote:
On 5 Dec, 09:27, wrote:

if it's raining I might want to get the Tube to
Shepherds Bush and then WLL - you get charged twice, more than if you
took a journey of equivalent length on the Tube, even changing lines.


No you don't. Oyster PAYG fares are based on the start and end points
of your journey. If you change trains at a recognised interchange,
even if you have to go through barriers or out onto the street, it
counts as a continuation of the same journey. In other words, in your
scenario, the second leg is free.


So changing between the Tube and the WLL at SB doesn't count as
changing mode?

If I travel from, say, St Paul's to Waterloo via Holborn changing onto
a bus from Kingsway, surely I pay £2.50, £1.50 for the Tube and £1.00
for the bus. If I do the same journey by going on as far as Tottenham
Court Road and get the Northern line it only costs me £1.50. My point
was that you should be able to do the first journey for the same price
as the second - I don't think you can.

John B December 5th 08 01:28 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On Dec 5, 1:52*pm, wrote:
if it's raining I might want to get the Tube to
Shepherds Bush and then WLL - you get charged twice, more than if you
took a journey of equivalent length on the Tube, even changing lines.


No you don't. Oyster PAYG fares are based on the start and end points
of your journey. If you change trains at a recognised interchange,
even if you have to go through barriers or out onto the street, it
counts as a continuation of the same journey. In other words, in your
scenario, the second leg is free.


So changing between the Tube and the WLL at SB doesn't count as
changing mode?

If I travel from, say, St Paul's to Waterloo via Holborn changing onto
a bus from Kingsway, surely I pay £2.50, £1.50 for the Tube and £1.00
for the bus. *If I do the same journey by going on as far as Tottenham
Court Road and get the Northern line it only costs me £1.50. *My point
was that you should be able to do the first journey for the same price
as the second - I don't think you can.


PAYG on the Overground (and on other NR lines where Oyster is
accepted) is treated the same as PAYG on the tube, and hence a journey
that involves both is only considered as one journey. I think this is
true for the DLR as well.

Buses are different. $deity knows why, although my guess would be
technical implementation reasons rather than an ideological dislike of
mixed-mode bus-rail journey.

--
John Band
john at johnband dot org
www.johnband.org

[email protected] December 5th 08 02:09 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
PAYG on the Overground (and on other NR lines where Oyster is
accepted) is treated the same as PAYG on the tube, and hence a journey
that involves both is only considered as one journey. I think this is
true for the DLR as well.


Buses are different. $deity knows why, although my guess would be
technical implementation reasons rather than an ideological dislike of
mixed-mode bus-rail journey.


I looked this up on the TfL website and it seems to be true. I have
to admit I didn't realise. Probably because I have only got my Oyster
since moving out of London, and my trips to London are now generally
confined more to the centre for both business and pleasure - so I am
less likely to use Overground services. On top of which there have
been a lot of changes in the last year or so. I know in the past I
have avoided using DLR because I thought I would be charged extra, but
then the stations are close together and I often like to walk anyway.

I suppose buses are different because there is no "end" checkout. But
they could easily bring in a rule whereby if you used a bus within,
say 30 minutes of the start of a recently completed Tube journey, you
wouldn't be charged.

Paul Scott December 5th 08 03:23 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
wrote:
PAYG on the Overground (and on other NR lines where Oyster is
accepted) is treated the same as PAYG on the tube, and hence a
journey that involves both is only considered as one journey. I
think this is true for the DLR as well.


Buses are different. $deity knows why, although my guess would be
technical implementation reasons rather than an ideological dislike
of mixed-mode bus-rail journey.


I looked this up on the TfL website and it seems to be true. I have
to admit I didn't realise.


It is valid for any pair of LU/LO/DLR/NR stations where the gates are
programmed for 'out of station interchange', or OSIs, however the list of
OSIs is not formally published. Station pairs explicitly linked on the
latest tube map, eg White City/Wood Lane, or Shepherds Bush LU/LO are OSIs;
as are implicit pairs like the two Hammersmiths. However it is incorrect to
assume all journeys involving a short walk outside the barriers will be
linked, but hopefully you have the picture now.

Paul S



Neil Williams December 5th 08 06:43 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On Fri, 5 Dec 2008 06:28:46 -0800 (PST), John B
wrote:

Buses are different. $deity knows why, although my guess would be
technical implementation reasons rather than an ideological dislike of
mixed-mode bus-rail journey.


Even between buses it doesn't give a discount, though. Surely it
would be logical to allow a second free touch-in on a bus if the
previous one was less than, say, an hour ago? That can't be hard to
implement.

Neil

--
Neil Williams
Put my first name before the at to reply.

Paul Corfield December 5th 08 06:54 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On Fri, 5 Dec 2008 16:23:25 -0000, "Paul Scott"
wrote:

wrote:
PAYG on the Overground (and on other NR lines where Oyster is
accepted) is treated the same as PAYG on the tube, and hence a
journey that involves both is only considered as one journey. I
think this is true for the DLR as well.


Buses are different. $deity knows why, although my guess would be
technical implementation reasons rather than an ideological dislike
of mixed-mode bus-rail journey.


I looked this up on the TfL website and it seems to be true. I have
to admit I didn't realise.


It is valid for any pair of LU/LO/DLR/NR stations where the gates are
programmed for 'out of station interchange', or OSIs, however the list of
OSIs is not formally published. Station pairs explicitly linked on the
latest tube map, eg White City/Wood Lane, or Shepherds Bush LU/LO are OSIs;
as are implicit pairs like the two Hammersmiths. However it is incorrect to
assume all journeys involving a short walk outside the barriers will be
linked, but hopefully you have the picture now.


The current list of OSIs has been compiled by London Reconnections and
verified by TfL.

http://londonreconnections.blogspot....s-current.html

--
Paul C

Paul Corfield December 5th 08 07:01 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On Fri, 05 Dec 2008 19:43:25 GMT, (Neil
Williams) wrote:

On Fri, 5 Dec 2008 06:28:46 -0800 (PST), John B
wrote:

Buses are different. $deity knows why, although my guess would be
technical implementation reasons rather than an ideological dislike of
mixed-mode bus-rail journey.


Even between buses it doesn't give a discount, though. Surely it
would be logical to allow a second free touch-in on a bus if the
previous one was less than, say, an hour ago? That can't be hard to
implement.


It might be logical but it would also cost a great deal of money in
terms of lost revenue. Hong Kong operators have used service cuts to
remove through services where a bus to bus interchange can be put in
place to give little or no financial penalty from changing buses. They
tend to run without fare subsidy so that sort of change to services is
needed to "finance" the lost revenue.

It's possible that over time ridership increases would compensate for
the lost revenue but it would still require short term funding. I
believe New York ended up with more revenue overall a few years after it
implemented free transfer (on PAYG Metrocard) between Subway and Bus to
give one fare for a through journey using both modes. TfL simply doesn't
have the cash to fund such a fundamental change. The other risk would
be that if ridership really did accelerate off the back of that fare
initiative that costs of providing contracted bus services would
increase thus making the cost impacts greater. I'm ignoring the benefit
side of the equation for now.
--
Paul C





MIG December 5th 08 10:14 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On Dec 5, 8:57*am, Mizter T wrote:
On 5 Dec, 00:39, wrote:





On 4 Dec, 16:52, "Graham Harrison"
wrote:


"Graeme Wall" wrote in message


Why bother, go to Waterloo then Bakerloo/Northern line (to taste)
and then Central Line to White City which is right opposite TV Centre.
Shepherds Bush is right the other end of Shepherds Bush Green and,
frankly, I wouldn't fancy walking back there from TVC after dark.


It's counter intuitive but how about Waterloo, Bakerloo or Jubilee to Baker
St then Hammersmith and City to the new station that I can't remember the
name of?


Google


Wood Lane, that's the one.


I didn't know they had built a new station... six months not working
in London and it seems I'm out of touch already.


Both the new stations at Wood Lane on the H&C and Shepherd's Bush on
the WLL have been built in connection with, and at least partially
financed by, Westfield - i.e. the bods who built, own and run the
mamoth new shopping centre there.


From what I've seen, people pour out of the WLL and head not for
Westfield but directly into the Central Line (as I did when I was last
that way); a bleedin obvious interchange need that waited for an
irrelevant commercial development to pay for it.

[email protected] December 6th 08 11:09 AM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 

But surely all you would need to do is to set other fares to
compensate? IMO this should have been factored in when they designed
the system: it's what most European systems do, and you can still get
transfare tickets in Newcastle, for example.

In any case, I am sure a lot of people will be making decisions based
on the cost. If travelling on the journey I gave as an example, I
would currently change at TCR for the Northern Line. If I could use
the bus for free, I would change at Holborn for a bus as I usually
reckon this is quicker. So no additional usage.


Paul Corfield December 6th 08 12:23 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On Sat, 6 Dec 2008 04:09:20 -0800 (PST),
wrote:


But surely all you would need to do is to set other fares to
compensate? IMO this should have been factored in when they designed
the system: it's what most European systems do, and you can still get
transfare tickets in Newcastle, for example.


Fares in London are currently hugely different between bus, tube and
rail. We need to be clear what we are talking about. I thought Neil was
referring to bus to bus interchange - if you allow the second journey
for free then that loss of revenue has to be funded somehow. If you
talking about bus to tube / rail or the reverse then fare scales are
very different indeed with tube / rail being zonal and bus being flat.
You could create a further fare scale that allowed through travel at one
price but there'd still be a discount over today's structure that would
have to be funded. I doubt it would be very popular if all the other
fares rose in order to create this structure.

The system was specified to allow single journey through ticketing - I
wrote the spec! Whether it was actually implemented in the design I do
not know as I changed jobs. Tyne and Wear is a different case
altogether - the original scheme was fully zonal and fares on Metro,
Ferry and Bus were common throughout Tyne and Wear prior to
deregulation. They had to be in order for the bus and metro integration
scheme to work. There were spin offs in that bus to bus transfer was
possible but only if you paid for a single (or more) zones. There were
short hop fare stages under the 1 Zone fare which meant some short
journeys involving a change might still be cheaper without a Transfare.
Post deregulation the scheme became "commercial" which stripped out bus
to bus interchange immediately, removed a lot of suburban interchange
points and narrowed the scheme to defined interchanges with the
objective being to reach Newcastle, Gateshead or Sunderland centres. The
only remnants left that still work as per the original scheme are routes
from Heworth to Washington and beyond where commercial bus services
still terminate at Heworth rather than run through to Newcastle.
Recently the honeycomb zone structure has been abandoned in favour of a
strange three zone structure for Transfares but the old limitations
remain.

In some cases there is operator specific through ticketing -
particularly from local services to the express routes that run from
Newcastle (Stagecoach 100) or Gateshead (Go Ahead X66) to the
Metrocentre. Go Ahead are experimenting with other types of through
tickets but that's only because they are breaking the bus network up
into a different structure and introducing connecting services in some
places.

In any case, I am sure a lot of people will be making decisions based
on the cost. If travelling on the journey I gave as an example, I
would currently change at TCR for the Northern Line. If I could use
the bus for free, I would change at Holborn for a bus as I usually
reckon this is quicker. So no additional usage.


If you were to reduce people's transport costs then typically you will
see an increase in ridership. Service quality is also a factor. Why else
do you imagine London's bus network has seen extraordinary growth over
the last few years?

Similar trends apply with rail services.
--
Paul C


Neil Williams December 7th 08 04:58 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
On Fri, 05 Dec 2008 20:01:52 +0000, Paul Corfield
wrote:

It might be logical but it would also cost a great deal of money in
terms of lost revenue. Hong Kong operators have used service cuts to
remove through services where a bus to bus interchange can be put in
place to give little or no financial penalty from changing buses.


Then perhaps the normal single fare should rise to cover it. It is to
me highly unfair that someone who has to use two buses because TfL
don't provide a direct one[1] are penalised over someone who might
make a very long direct journey.

I suppose the cap almost deals with it for someone doing a return
journey, but for a single journey it to me[2] isn't right.

[1] Not that they should. But there are odd gaps in the network, e.g.
nothing from Euston to the Blackfriars area without a change. The
change at Kings Cross is probably the best way to serve the market,
but the added cost is unfair.

[2] Not me directly, as I have an outboundary Travelcard season.

Neil

--
Neil Williams
Put my first name before the at to reply.

[email protected] December 8th 08 12:34 AM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
In article ,
(Paul Corfield) wrote:

On Fri, 5 Dec 2008 16:23:25 -0000, "Paul Scott"
wrote:

wrote:
PAYG on the Overground (and on other NR lines where Oyster is
accepted) is treated the same as PAYG on the tube, and hence a
journey that involves both is only considered as one journey. I
think this is true for the DLR as well.

Buses are different. $deity knows why, although my guess would be
technical implementation reasons rather than an ideological dislike
of mixed-mode bus-rail journey.

I looked this up on the TfL website and it seems to be true. I have
to admit I didn't realise.


It is valid for any pair of LU/LO/DLR/NR stations where the gates are
programmed for 'out of station interchange', or OSIs, however the list
of OSIs is not formally published. Station pairs explicitly linked on
the latest tube map, eg White City/Wood Lane, or Shepherds Bush LU/LO
are OSIs; as are implicit pairs like the two Hammersmiths. However it
is incorrect to assume all journeys involving a short walk outside the
barriers will be linked, but hopefully you have the picture now.


The current list of OSIs has been compiled by London Reconnections and
verified by TfL.

http://londonreconnections.blogspot....-station-inter
changes-current.html


There seem to be a few glitches there, e.g.

London King's Cross LU King's Cross St. Pancras Met NR 30
London King's Cross LU King's Cross St. Pancras Tube NR 30

which should have NR and LU reversed, surely?

Also, I see there are still OSIs for:

King's Cross St. Pancras Met LU King's Cross St. Pancras Tube LU 30

and vice-versa are still in there. Surely they are no longer OSIs since
the Met station was reconfigured with the Western ticket hall?

--
Colin Rosenstiel

[email protected] December 8th 08 12:34 AM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
In article
,
() wrote:

It looks like there are now only TfL fares on that route, not NR ones,
and you can't combine them with a super off peak.

So for some reason it seems you can book "anytime return to CJ +
anytime return from CJ to SB" or "off peak return to CJ + anytime
return from CJ to SB" but not "super off peak return to CJ + anytime
return from CJ to SB".

The NRE website doesn't give the London Stations fare for Olympia
either.


More collapsing fare integration inside and outside of London! Given how
much we outside London pay to subsidise TfL and NR services in London it's
a scandal!

--
Colin Rosenstiel

Paul Scott December 8th 08 10:23 AM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
wrote:

The NRE website doesn't give the London Stations fare for Olympia
either.


If you mean the 'London Terminals' fare, that'll be because Kensington
Olympia isn't a member of the 'London Terminals' fares group. Changed in
the mid 90s IIRC.

Kenny O is however a valid interchange for cross London NR/LU/NR transfer.

Paul S




Paul Scott December 8th 08 10:25 AM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
wrote:
In article
,
() wrote:

It looks like there are now only TfL fares on that route, not NR
ones, and you can't combine them with a super off peak.

So for some reason it seems you can book "anytime return to CJ +
anytime return from CJ to SB" or "off peak return to CJ + anytime
return from CJ to SB" but not "super off peak return to CJ + anytime
return from CJ to SB".

The NRE website doesn't give the London Stations fare for Olympia
either.


More collapsing fare integration inside and outside of London! Given
how much we outside London pay to subsidise TfL and NR services in
London it's a scandal!


The previous poster was wrong Colin, Anytime and Offpeak through fares are
available as per normal, it is only the SWT specific SOP that isn't.

Paul S



Paul Scott December 8th 08 10:36 AM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
wrote:

King's Cross St. Pancras Met LU King's Cross St. Pancras Tube LU 30

and vice-versa are still in there. Surely they are no longer OSIs
since the Met station was reconfigured with the Western ticket hall?


Probably makes sense to leave them as OSIs for the benefit of the few
irregular travellers who remember having to pass through the gatelines at KX
to get to/from Met/Circle to/from 'tube' and fail to notice the new signs or
routes. Doesn't cause any harm anyway AFAICT...

Paul S



[email protected] December 8th 08 01:50 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
In article ,
(Paul Scott) wrote:

wrote:
In article

,
() wrote:

It looks like there are now only TfL fares on that route, not NR
ones, and you can't combine them with a super off peak.

So for some reason it seems you can book "anytime return to CJ +
anytime return from CJ to SB" or "off peak return to CJ + anytime
return from CJ to SB" but not "super off peak return to CJ + anytime
return from CJ to SB".

The NRE website doesn't give the London Stations fare for Olympia
either.


More collapsing fare integration inside and outside of London! Given
how much we outside London pay to subsidise TfL and NR services in
London it's a scandal!


The previous poster was wrong Colin, Anytime and Offpeak through
fares are available as per normal, it is only the SWT specific SOP
that isn't.


Doesn't alter my complaint, that once you cross TOC boundaries, fare
integration goes pear shaped.

--
Colin Rosenstiel

[email protected] December 8th 08 01:50 PM

Fares to Shepherd's Bush Overground
 
In article ,
(Paul Scott) wrote:

wrote:

King's Cross St. Pancras Met LU King's Cross St. Pancras Tube LU 30

and vice-versa are still in there. Surely they are no longer OSIs
since the Met station was reconfigured with the Western ticket
hall?


Probably makes sense to leave them as OSIs for the benefit of the
few irregular travellers who remember having to pass through the
gatelines at KX to get to/from Met/Circle to/from 'tube' and fail
to notice the new signs or routes. Doesn't cause any harm anyway
AFAICT...


'spose so.

--
Colin Rosenstiel


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:15 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2006 LondonBanter.co.uk